1.
Graduated in high ranks for the class of the 2014 College of the Holy Cross Historian Association
Comments:
Fact: Moran has collected enough artifacts over his career to open 100 smithsonians.
2.
inventor of "scientific history" and probably the greatest historian of the nineteenth century.
3.
4.
5.
6.
7.
8.
The great English historian of the eighteenth century, author of the Decline and Fall of the Roman Empire.
9.
10.
She writes stories that reflect on the present in a way accessible to the present-day reader.
Comments:
Very overlooked and versatile. "Distant Mirror" is a classic on medieval Europe while "Proud Tower" and "Guns of August" are sharp on the coming and start of WW1. Her book on Stillwell and China covers WW2. Even "March of Folly" shows amazing versatility as she goes from Troy to papal decisions before the Reformation to the British handling of the coming of the American Revolution to the American experience in Vietnam. Lost steam at the end with "First Salute" which was published after her death. A masterful historian.
11.
12.
13.
(1796-1859) Possibly the greatest American historian of the 19th century, and author of the History of the Conquest of Mexico, the History of the Conquest of Peru, and the History of Ferdinand and Isabella.
15.
16.
Comments:
Solid nitty-gritty historian of the Civil War. Stands up solidly "yonder like a stonewall" against neo-confederate myth-making that the Civil War was not about slavery. Check out the Texas, Mississippi, Georgia, and South Carolina declarations of causes of secession, and Confederate VP Alexander Stephens "Cornerstone Speech" if you have any doubts.
17.
18.
Comments:
His work unbelievable and even i think he is my best historian after Herodotous and Al Masudi.He described all events thoroughly as well as interesting way.
22.
25.
Comments:
Best known as a philosopher and a sociologist, Focault has made, however, essential contributions to contemporary history. His ideas opened a wide range of new fields of research, mainly in social and cultural history. Subjects like minorities or thought systems history owe a lot to his works.
26.
27.
Comments:
Zinn's listened to the majority of people in history who had been silenced - women, blacks, workers, farmers, Latinos, etc. Previously, many historians consciously or unconsciously excluded them. What had been taught as "real" core history. was mainly that of white male elites. Zinn began when there was less material on outsiders than there is today. His effort to include, say Native Americans might seem schematic now, but today we have more to work with - to a great extent because Zinn's work.
Howard Zinn does not just look at outsiders. He looks at history from their' point of view. People accustomed to insiders' vantage point of see him as biased because he includes what had been missing.
Zinn and other social historians, such as Eric Hobsbawm have also shown outsiders to be makers of history not just passive victims. Without this: 1. History has moral blinders 2. It fails to see key forces at work - like trying to understand a whale, without looking at the sea, or the other creatures great and small that affect it.
National elites often expect historians to serve as patriotic cheer leaders. Social science has tried to reject cheer leading, and look at reality. Ask a typical college class how many have heard of the Boston Massacre (almost all) versus the My Lai Massacre one or two). Old fashioned biases are alive and well.
Conservatives say Zinn is biased for telling the truth about genocide, slavery, or the price of war that he observed as a bombardier in World War II. Rather than say he is biased for illuminating the dark parts of our history real historians are looking at what he brought to light.
In response to the criticisms:
Howard Zinn's work is not free from inaccuracies, as is the case with every historian, but his contribution as a social historian is undeniable in understanding American history. He made a very important point that the perspective of a historian is always the product of his ideology, and because bias is inevitable one must choose whether he should look at it through the eyes of the elites, or those 'from below'. His magnum opus, "People's History" should be required reading for any student of American history in addition to the works of those like Eric Foner.
I'm afraid some confuse fame with greatness. Mr. Zinn took a proctologist's view of history and of the U.S. -- fact-based, but preoccupied, dismissing the the great scope, complexity, and beauty of the human condition. He once said the world would have been better off if the U.S. had never been consummated. His thinking reflects the opposite of wisdom.
29.
Author of the critically acclaimed 3000 page 1.5 million word history of the American Civil War.
30.
Carlyle's portentous, oracular Style and extravagant Vocabulary (no more normal in the 19th century than they'd be today) can make you think he's a crank, but his French Revolution is a candidate for the most interesting, penetrating and exciting volume of history ever written. Few historians have been equally deep philosophers, and none I know of has matched his understanding of how the exceptional figure interacts with the unruly masses.
31.
35.
Byzantium afeter Byzantium, History of the Ottoman Empire, History of the Venitian Republic, History of Romania through Its Travellers, History of Albania,
38.
39.
Although rightly or wrongly criticized for his biases, Parkman was a most thorough researcher and expounded well and engagingly the story of widely different cultures coming to clash in 17th and 18th century North America.
41.
Similar Top lists
Category | Ranked | Added by | |
---|---|---|---|
20 Greatest Stand Up Comedians | People | 239 items | pxc0 |
Great Lawyers in History (and Fiction!) | People | 21 items | JDBLists |
Greatest Generals in History | People | 124 items | shazy |
Greatest Renaissance Sculptors | People | 20 items | xeniam |
ShareRanks is about ranking things that are top, most, greatest, or even worst in all categories.
Use arrows to rank one item in Greatest Historians vs another.
Use arrows to rank one item in Greatest Historians vs another.
Top 10 Greatest Historians are especially marked