1.
Larry Fitzgerald
20 points - added 14 years ago by kris -
2.
Peyton Manning
Did a lot without a lot, and they finally were the champs … the year after he left
18 points - added 14 years ago by kris - 1 comment
Comments:
Payton lost the Heisman only because this was the best legitimate chance that a defensive player had of winning the Heisman.
That, in my opinion, is a poor excuse to deny Manning the Heisman Trophy.
Added 10 years ago by guest, 0 points
3.
Marshall Faulk
17 points - added 14 years ago by kris -
4.
John Elway
15 points - added 14 years ago by kris -
5.
Herschel Walker
He won it the next year, by the way
13 points - added 14 years ago by kris - 1 comment
Comments:
Certainly he should have also won it his Freshman year(1980); voters gave it to a Senior, George Rogers, because it wasn't customary to award a Freshman, back then. #Herschel: the most dominant RB ever! 3 years, many records.
Added 9 years ago by guest, 0 points
6.
Ki-Jana Carter
Ran like a wildfire on a dominant Penn State team
12 points - added 14 years ago by kris -
7.
Hugh Green
12 points - added 14 years ago by kris -
8.
Adrian Peterson
10 points - added 14 years ago by kris -
9.
Darren McFadden
His execution and playmaking ability is the reason that the “Wildcat” exists today
9 points - added 14 years ago by kris -
10.
Steve Young
8 points - added 14 years ago by kris -
11.
Tommie Frazier
7 points - added 14 years ago by kris -
12.
keith byers
6 points - added 12 years ago by redbarron80 -
13.
Joe Theismann
6 points - added 14 years ago by kris -
14.
Brad Banks
6 points - added 14 years ago by kris -
15.
Christian McCaffrey
Broke Barry Sanders's NCAA record of 3,250 all-purpose yards, finishing with 3,864.
5 points - added 7 years ago by guest -
16.
Colt McCoy
Holds the NCAA record for wins, no one has had as many victories as he has
4 points - added 14 years ago by kris -
17.
Greg Pruitt
3 points - added 14 years ago by kris -
18.
Mike Phipps
3 points - added 14 years ago by kris -
19.
Rex Grossman
2 points - added 14 years ago by kris -
20.
Toby Gerhart
1 point - added 14 years ago by kris -
21.
Vince Young
Single handedly willed his team to a national championship, week in and week out
-2 points - added 14 years ago by kris -
22.
O.J. Simpson
-19 points - added 14 years ago by kris -
ShareRanks is about ranking things that are top, most, greatest, or even worst in all categories.
Use arrows to rank one item in versus another.
Use arrows to rank one item in versus another.
Top 10 Heisman Trophy Runner Ups are especially marked