1.
Joe Montana
Like Marino, Montana is one of the best ever, but his reign was more 80s than 90s. Still did great things with the 49ers and Chiefs from 90-94.
84 points - added 13 years ago by plink - 1 comment
Comments:
Montana's my fave player of all time, but all his achievements, excepting 1990's NFL MVP, were in the 80s, no way should he be no.1 in this list, playing as he did in only 3 seasons(he missed ALL of '91 and you CANNOT count half a game versus Detroit in 1992).
Yes, he had good years in '93 and '94, but they were NOT years comparable with his great seasons of the 80s, and certainly not comparable with the equivalent seasons of, for example, Steve Young, who topped the league in passing with in both of those seasons(as well as FOUR OTHERS in the 90s) and who won a Superbowl in the second of those two.
Much as I love Joe, he is nowhere near no.1 for the 90s. 80's yes, sure. All time? Maybe, based on his 80s performance, but no way could you seriously suggest he was the quarterback of the 90s.
Added 11 years ago by guest, 1 point
2.
Brett Favre
Where to begin? Three straight MVPs ('95, '96, '97), two Super Bowls, winning Super Bowl XXXI. Before he spent each off-season debating retirement, he was simply stunning.
44 points - added 13 years ago by plink -
3.
Steve Young
Seven Pro Bowls and threw SIX touchdowns in Super Bowl XXIX (which they won, with Young as MVP)
42 points - added 13 years ago by plink - 1 comment
Comments:
Why does everyone evaluate QBs on stats, ask anyone who watched both Montana & Younf at will tell you they'd take Montana in a sec, all these Young voters never watched Montana! Don't compare a whiney Young to Joe, he deserves better!
Added 11 years ago by guest, -1 points
4.
John Elway
After a hall of fame career, Elway finally earned his first Super Bowl in 1998. Then what did he do in 1999? He won the Super Bowl again. Then what did he do? He retried...maybe the only great QB to retire at the right time.
39 points - added 13 years ago by plink - 1 comment
Comments:
I think John Elway should be one or two quaterback.
Added 12 years ago by guest, 0 points
5.
Dan Marino
One of the best of all time, most of his glory was in the 80s. However, he left his stamp on the 90s with continued excellence.
37 points - added 13 years ago by plink -
6.
Kurt Warner
1999.
36 points - added 13 years ago by plink - 1 comment
Comments:
Exactly... 1999, I would put Steve McNair ahead of Warner in this case
Added 9 years ago by guest, 0 points
7.
Troy Aikman
If a QB is measured by championships, Troy Aikman is Number 1 of this decade winning three Super Bowls. The leader of one of the best teams in NFL history, he put up staggering numbers and was voted to six consecutive Pro Bowls.
27 points - added 13 years ago by plink - 1 comment
Comments:
Staggeringly average... Staggering is not a word that should be used for a QB who only once in his career threw over 20 TDs in a season (game manager) did Alex Smith ever put up staggering numbers?
Added 9 years ago by guest, 2 points
8.
Warren Moon
Nine Pro Bowls and held a variety of NFL records, including most passing yards (records later broken by Favre)...
24 points - added 13 years ago by plink -
9.
Jim Kelly
Nobody has done what Jim has done. Four straight Super Bowl appearances. What's the bigger achievement, lead your team to four in a row or win one?
19 points - added 13 years ago by plink -
10.
Mark Rypien
MVP of Super Bowl XXVI.
16 points - added 13 years ago by plink -
11.
Drew Bledsoe
Took the Patriots to two Super Bowls and himself to four Pro Bowls.
10 points - added 13 years ago by plink -
12.
Jim Harbaugh
Captain Comback.
8 points - added 13 years ago by plink -
13.
Mark Brunell
Put the Jags on the map.
6 points - added 13 years ago by plink -
14.
Randall Cunningham
4 points - added 13 years ago by plink -
15.
Chris Chandler
Pro Bowler in '97 and '98, he lead the Falcons to their only Super Bowl 1998.
3 points - added 13 years ago by plink -
16.
Brad Johnson
A Super Bowl would fall on him in the 2000s, but he earned a decent street cred in the 90s, namely with the Vikings and became the first Redskin QB to pass for over 4,000 yards.
3 points - added 13 years ago by plink -
17.
Trent Dilfer
Took the Buccs to their first playoff appearance in 15 years.
3 points - added 13 years ago by plink -
18.
Vinny Testaverde
Chances are, at some point, Vinny played for your home team.
1 point - added 13 years ago by plink -
19.
Steve Beuerlein
-3 points - added 13 years ago by plink -
20.
Scott Mitchell
Have the Lions, really, had a better quarterback?
-5 points - added 13 years ago by plink - 2 comments
Comments:
Steve McNair, Kerry Collins deserves a nod for putting Carolina on the map, Jeff Blake, all names that belong ahead of McNair
Added 9 years ago by guest, -1 points
What the hell does that have to do with Scott Mitchell making your top 20???
Hmm..also..Mark Rypien, Randal Cunningham & especially Mark Brunell, Warren Moon and Jim Harbaugh all better than Bledsoe?? Whaaaat? That's Crazy!! Even Warner is a stretch, he landed on a super stacked team, don't get me wrong he was awesome but that's like saying Bledsoe or any other of your top 6 couldn't have done the same thing in the same situation! Think Bledsoe is being evaluated on the latter part of his career here. Again the fact that Mitchell is even on this list is belly aching laughable, Jeff George(whom I'm not a fan at all came in at tail end of his career and took B Jonson's job) Geesh, it's not about stats, it's about who do you want to come in and win you a game, Scott Mitchell, chg careers to standup!
Added 11 years ago by guest, 0 points
Similar Top lists
| Category | Ranked | Added by | |
|---|---|---|---|
| Best NFL Quarterbacks 2000s | Sports | 21 items | plink |
| Best NFL Quarterbacks 1980s | Sports | 23 items | plink |
| Best NFL Quarterbacks 1970s | Sports | 24 items | plink |
| Best WWF/WWE Matches In 1989 | Sports | 27 items | kris |
| 20 Top Ranked NFL Quarterbacks | Sports | 21 items | kris |
ShareRanks is about ranking things that are top, most, greatest, or even worst in all categories.
Use arrows to rank one item in versus another.
Use arrows to rank one item in versus another.
Top 10 Best NFL Quarterbacks 1990s are especially marked