1.
A sweet and true song that really personalizes the image of the soldier.
Comments:
this song did get to me before i deployed. got to me even more when i finally would get a letter.
wow right before i got deployed i listened to this song and it really made me think about how all of you people think of me and i very appreciate it and so does god and i want to thank everyone out there who supports us :")
Wow!! I cry everytime they say son you make me proud cuz I wud start sobbing if my dad told me that!
2.
Comments:
those who are talking bad about the dixie chicks are mistaken. at least they had enough guts to stand up and write music about the people who are fighting for our country and their loved ones. I LOVE this song. when my boyfriend got sent over i listened to this song all the time and i cried everytime almost I LOVE this song !!!!
I love the Dixie Chicks...even more for speaking their minds about idiot Bush II.
I applaud those who served, and serve. My husband's currently overseas. However, this is a powerful song, despite the ranting and ravings of an ignorant country singer,
Idk what u all are talking about this song is AMAZING I can listen to it 50 times in a row and cry EVERY TIME!!! There is NOTHING wrong with this song
Their use of Freedom of Speech is Terrific! And I applaud them for invoking their Right. They have Every Right to Disagree with Politics and Policies. But doing so in the Homeland (United States) is One Thing. Saying you're not proud of the Leader of Your Country... when your Overseas... has a Totally Different MEANING. It's One Thing... to protest, demonstrate, and disagree inside the U.S.....and it's a different thing when you're a public figure (like a Popular Band)... and tell Foreigners that you're Ashamed of Calling your President... a Texan. Can't anyone SEE the Difference?
Wat thy "did" is protected by the constitution I fought to defend. You belittle my service and all soliders with your rants. They have always supported the members of the armed services. We all have not only the right but the duty to call out the washington piheads who misreresent things.
"what they did"? Do you mean expressing an anti-war opinion that is inherent and present in classic country ie Loretta Lynn and Johnny Cash. I think modern pop-country like Toby Keith has caused some amnesia about country roots and voice. Does anyone remember why Johnny Cash was The Man in Black?
With what the dixie chicks did I dont see how you can put this song at #2. I truly cant stand them and neither can most people. Terrible #2 choice.
5.
The lines of this song show the willingness and yet the reluctance of giving everything for one’s country.
Comments:
everytime i hear this song i think about the bravest men in our country that put their lives on the line to protect what we have. freedom does not come free. im proud to be an American and i respect our military. god bless america
6.
Comments:
My boyfriend just went to training and my cousin is in Turkey.. they are both in the airforce. and watching them leave is honestly the hardest thing ive ever had to do. This song made me cry for like an hour. I miss them so much Thank you soldiers ! your amazing and i love you all ! .
It's a very sad song, but it's exactly like how it is over there. Trust me, i know.
When i first heard this song, i burst into tears. I'm really working on fighting off my depression and this song really nailed it. When i got home everyone called me a hero, but honestly i didn't really feel like a hero, and he is right there is a medal over my chest, but it means something totally different to me than it does to everyone else. Also, mistakes happen in war, and i think that is more what he is talking about versus soldiers violating UCMJ.
If you look at the comments, and notice those that are enlisted, they respect this song.
A song doesn't have to sing praise towards us, for that is not what a soldier joins for. The song means something, it means something more then most of the others don't.
You don't join to be a hero.
You join to make the world a better place, in a way many people don't understand. That effort, in most cases, comes at a tragic cost.
Every time I hear this song it evokes real emotions, and things I cannot express in words alone.
I'm in the army myself. I really do respect this song. This isn't disrespectful in my opinion in any sense. This is someone who left so he could be a hero of war. Someone who wanted to be bigger and make more of a difference in the world than he felt he could make in the civilian world. But what he finds out is there is a lot more that happens in war than you think. And he falls into it. In the end he regrets it all. He realises that doing all of the things he did, didn't make him a hero of war. And treating and killing innocent people like he did only made him a bad person. He regrets killing the little girl, hince why he brings the flag home. The flag is a symbol of true freedom in his mind. Not the american flag.
this is such a good song .its saying "why should we be considered heros when we have to do such terrible things "
my mother was in the army as a combat medic. she hates this song but we have different view points. she says that this song is disrespecting the soldier, i say its saying **** happen/ they didn't know what they wanted when they sighed, stress and panick may have been the issue for the video of shooting the little girl. Almost all of my family was military mostly consisting of Marines and Army so i did grow up with hearing stories and i plan on going in myself, in my opinion i think the band was trying to get the public to see that soldiers are put through traumatic experiences, they make mistakes and well, stuff happens under stress, they're not perfect but even so they r proud to serve their country.
I was in afghanistan for a year and was shot at on a daily basis and i can relate to everything in this song... you never knew who you could trust or what was goin to happen... all you knew is that you needed to live, survive, for the loved ones home... and you would do anything to get home to them... you dont know what a year of something trumatic can do to a person, and soldiers, especially infantry and recon, should be heroized for it
To the second comment, i agree and am hoping to join the nrotc marine option program and be a proud member of the USMC. I could go off and make a good living in the business sector but I wish to serve our country and am thankful for all those who have sacraficed for us all
WOW! this song is amazing! My Brother is the one who introduce this song to me! He is a Air Man and really respect s this song.. And those who have to go threw Deployment and sacrifices much more greater than civilians. So stop saying this song is bad for this list! its actually ONE OF THEE BEST! * Thank you those of those soldiers who serve our country, and fight to made our freedom enjoyable!(:
Alot of you didn't like this song. However it is from the soldiers point of view and it may not be all but it may be some who like and understand and those of u who do congrats
To those bashing the USN Officer, LEARN TO READ! He said MOST soldiers, not ALL. For those Soldiers who joined because they wanted the money, I admire what you have done and sacrificed for us, but, truth is.. If you're going for the money then it's not the same. Yes, you do make the same sacrifices and fight the same way and such, but, you're there for the wrong reasons. Or, you joined for the wrong reasons, atleast. I honour and deeply admire and respect Soldiers, Sailors, Marines and Airmen alike. You've given and sacrificed so much for your country(ies) and/or state(s). On behalf of one deeply grateful, eternally thankful civillian I say, Thank You for having the courage to stand up for all of us.
I suffer from PTSD because of what's sang in this song. The comments posted about this song our from soldiers who were fobits. As an infantry soldier this song is all facts. Anyone who says otherwise sat on a fob their entire tour of Iraq. For those of us who had to fight we were put in these situations time and time again
totally agree, not a pro mil song at all...bummer too, bc I actually like Rise Against. But I know my dad's 30 years in the Army was worth it. God bless our Soldiers, Sailors, Marines and Airmen.
after getting out of the military after 15 years I have to disagree, yeah I joined because there weren't many options open to me but I could have done other things but saying that no soldier but those 20 that did it solely out of patriotism did it for their country is kind of false. I've known recruits of all kinds and country was always a factor.
to the second comment, i just left ft benning about 2 weeks ago, and out of the 600 or so guys i knew there maybe 20 or 30 were doing it cuz they were patriotic, id say most were cuz they had no other options, then college, then guys just wanten to go sf or ranger to push themselves and be able to say they did what few other have done. but just a handful did it for country.
im trying to jump on my first deployment right now so i can't say from personal experiance but from what all my sgts and friends who have gone say this hits the nail on the head. Most of us arn't there cuz we like being soldiers we're there cuz we need money or we want to go to school. and when we get tossed into this war...you do stuff and you don't always do the right thing, but you do you're best. cuz i don't know anyone who'd risk there life for oil that they'll never see profit from, but i know atleast 218 men who willl lay down there lives for there wives children parents siblings random strangers or a promise that their death helped to make a better life for someone. as they say over and over i want to be a hero of war...and ps he wouldn't be tried under umcj cuz he couldn't see she was waving a flag, and she was entering a restricted area, i had a ds who shot a 80 year old man driving a truck and killed like 2 kids and they let it go, not that it matters doing something like that would kill you. we're soldiers, were not perfect, but our hearts are mostly in the right place. and i think thats what they were getting at.
For the first comment: Im also a soldier in the british army and i saw the video and heard the song and it is a contridiction not a statement. the song is saying that going to war does not make you a hero that is why the flag he loved at the end was the white flag of surrender that he brought home from the civvie that he shot. You Americans eh lol
Not only this but It's very inaccurate and inconsistent with history and the current conflicts. As a USN officer and descendant of a line of fighting men since the War for Independence I can tell you this song is very disrespectful, most soldiers and sailors didn't volunteer because they were conned into it. Most are patriotic young Americans who want to make a difference and their officers are good human beings who would never order such an event.
Yeah, beating a prisoner of war and shooting a girl who is surrendering.. Yes, this sometimes happend but i wouldnt qualify it to be the best military or soldier song. I'm a soldier and the things sang about does not make you a hero, it makes you a criminal under UMCJ and is why most soldiers will never do such a thing.
7.
A more upbeat song about soldiers, describing a soldier still doing his duty to protect long after his death.
9.
Comments:
this song really does remind me of my corporal. I miss him so much.
If you like this song listen to the reply by Tyler toliver called "Live our dream"
10.
This powerful anti-war song written in 1970 by Steve Goodman amidst the Vietnam war proves that we still have learned nothing from all the conflicts.
Comments:
I'd never heard this song before so i looked it up and listened with tears running down my face. I've served in Iraq and Afghanistan both and known men and women who died there leaving families back home. This song really brought home the pain I know they feel every day.
12.
John Prine song about a soldier who comes back from the Vietnam war with a wound and has to take more and more pain killers which eventually leads to harder drugs and self destruction.
16.
Comments:
This song is great, cause I was just in the Stan and the end of september was when we left Sangin.
even though it's about his father's passing, the entire song could be interpreted to be about losing a father in war. regardless of what the song IS about, it COULD be about that to a certain person.
Although I agree that the video has nothing to do with the original meaning of the song, the whole point of music is to take from it your own interpretation. So this song could be about war if that's what it means to you.
the video has nothing to do with the meaning. He told a crowd at a concert it was about his dad dying.
Agreed. Just because a music videos usually alter the true meaning of a song. Billie's father died on September 1, and told his mother to "wake me up when September ends."
Really? "Watch the music video"? Videos don't really have anything to do with what the songs actually about most of the time.
17.
A beautiful song that describes the connection soldiers have for each other and the lasting impact of war.
19.
Comments:
Most ppl would relate this song to Air Force Basic Training. This is a great song, gives you hope. Lets you know that you have a chance to make it back home. Thats all you want, is to get back home.
The most moving, beautiful and inspiring song a mother can listen to when her son is going into the service.
oh my gosh i just listened to that song for the first time and cried my eyes out! my fiance is in the army so it really took my heart for a spin. that is a wonderful song and its given me hope that my fiance will come back alive and well.
Ive been singing this song for as long as i can remember. Ive seen neighbors come ad go, but i never knew what it was truely like until a very close cousin of mine joined the national guard.
22.
Comments:
This song is a military song. It is a look into a soldiers mind and how he handles taking an enemies life. Sad song.
24.
Comments:
You can't be TOO patriotic. I take offense to that. I'm a military wife & my husband is in Iraq...I can't even talk to him so I don't have the slightest clue how he's doing. So maybe you should be a little more grateful to those who are risking and even giving their lives for your freedom, even if it takes them away from their families.
26.
This song is about a soldier who has returned home and is bearing the scars of war (i.e.: his dreams and his conscience).
29.
This song is AMAZING and should move to the top of the list! Heard it on country radio--gave me chills and I sent to my friends in Iraq and Afghanistan.
35.
For soldiers going to war, remember those left behind.
Don't let them wait around for the heartbreak.
37.
Its a song about a stretch of highway in Canada that soldiers who have given their lives over seas are brought down to the base in Trenton. It is a beautiful and powerful song.
43.
A beautiful song about those who miss their loved ones.
Comments:
i danced to this song in my dance recital this past year. the teacher and choreographer is engaged to a military soldier. we danced this dance three times becasue everyone claimed it was so beautiful and moving. not one person in that audiance was left untouched by that dance and most people cried. this is such a powerful song.
49.
This song talks about the soldier fighting for his life and the scars he bears from his experiences in war.
54.
60.
62.
65.
68.
A heartbreaking song about the condemnation of boys being forced to draft into the military and going off to die.
69.
70.
72.
Amazing song about how our members of the military are there for each other and wont' come home "til the last shots fired"
74.
75.
Very inspirational. It's pretty much about being beaten down, and when you cant fight anymore, but then you need to get up and look ahead and see you can get through it if you remeber who you are.
76.
80.
Because it's about all about soldiers and i miss my brother who died in Afghanistan. This song helped me a lot.
81.
This is an amazing song. My man is in Afghanistan right now and this song makes it a little easier sometimes when he doesn't get to call but once in a while.
82.
84.
Sorry if this is up somewhere and I never noticed, this song is sad but definatly a different twist on the heros of war.
85.
about a soldier using a deck cards for a bible and almanac during the war
86.
87.
88.
It's an incredibly sad song about a guy who decides to "take a flag to a pawn shop" and learns a bit about patriotism.
89.
Because it's about how war is a terrible thing and should end.
91.
This is a song made by swedish power/heavy metal band Sabaton. It's about 2700 brave polish soldiers, who fought against 42 000 germans in 1939, in the beginning of WWII. Whole situation is now called "polish Termophylae" .
92.
93.
95.
96.
97.
an incrdible song that you just have to hear if you love our military
98.
Song about what it's like for those who have lost a soldier of their own
Similar Top lists
| Category | Ranked | Added by | |
|---|---|---|---|
| Top Songs of the 20th Century | Music | 31 items | arollison |
| Top Bands Signed to Tooth and Nail Records | Music | 22 items | BrendaKaye |
| Top 20 Songs By Duran Duran | Music | 24 items | kris |
| Songs by Peter Paul and Mary | Music | 20 items | writer_girl |
| Songs by Muddy Waters | Music | 19 items | writer_girl |
ShareRanks is about ranking things that are top, most, greatest, or even worst in all categories.
Use arrows to rank one item in versus another.
Use arrows to rank one item in versus another.
Top 10 Top Songs about Soldiers and War are especially marked









