Vote + to improve this toplist's ranking
Report Abuse

Best Discontinued Ben and Jerry's Ice Cream Flavors

31 items ranked

Each year Ben and Jerry's discontinues some of its ice creams and puts them in the ice cream "flavor graveyard." Which discontinued flavors were the best?

Rated 12 points - posted 8 years ago by Peter in category Food & Drink.
Click on up and down arrows to affect item's ranking
Visit our Food and Drink forum



1.

Vote + to improve this item's ranking
Vote - to decrease this item's ranking
Oatmeal Cookie Report Abuse
Simply the best!!
44 points - added 6 years ago by guest -

2.

Vote + to improve this item's ranking
Vote - to decrease this item's ranking
KAberry KAboom Report Abuse
AMAZING BERRY FLAVOR. IT was the creamiest more amazing ice cream EVER.
30 points - added 7 years ago by guest - 4 comments
Comments:
would do anything for this.flavor to return
Added 1 year ago by guest, 0 points Vote + to improve this comment's ranking Vote - to decrease this comment's ranking
please bring this back it was my all time favorite please bring back!! ever time i pass a freezer in the store i look for this seriously
Added 1 year ago by guest, 0 points Vote + to improve this comment's ranking Vote - to decrease this comment's ranking
Best one ever!!!!!!! Hate that it is gone.....
Added 4 years ago by guest, 0 points Vote + to improve this comment's ranking Vote - to decrease this comment's ranking
damn the loss of Kaberry Kaboom blew us away!!!! My husband is now in morning---is there away to get it reserected from the garveyard????
Added 6 years ago by guest, 1 point Vote + to improve this comment's ranking Vote - to decrease this comment's ranking

3.

Vote + to improve this item's ranking
Vote - to decrease this item's ranking
Cool Britannia Report Abuse
strawberries and chocolate covered shortbread - it was sooooooo good.
29 points - added 7 years ago by guest - 5 comments
Comments:
Omg I wish I could get some of that right now. How can I petition to get ben n jerry to bring it back.?
Added 4 years ago by guest, 0 points Vote + to improve this comment's ranking Vote - to decrease this comment's ranking
This was the best!
Added 4 years ago by guest, 0 points Vote + to improve this comment's ranking Vote - to decrease this comment's ranking
I forgot about that stuff!176 It was soooo good!!
Added 5 years ago by guest, 1 point Vote + to improve this comment's ranking Vote - to decrease this comment's ranking
yeah that stuff was soooo good. wiish they would bring it back!!
Added 5 years ago by guest, 1 point Vote + to improve this comment's ranking Vote - to decrease this comment's ranking
best ice cream ever!
Added 5 years ago by guest, 2 points Vote + to improve this comment's ranking Vote - to decrease this comment's ranking

4.

Vote + to improve this item's ranking
Vote - to decrease this item's ranking
Chocolate Chip Cookie Dough Report Abuse
its a amazing flavor!
29 points - added 8 years ago by guest - 1 comment
Comments:
ben and jerrys still has this flavor you wiedo
Added 6 years ago by guest, 3 points Vote + to improve this comment's ranking Vote - to decrease this comment's ranking

5.

Vote + to improve this item's ranking
Vote - to decrease this item's ranking
Rainforest Crunch Report Abuse
27 points - added 8 years ago by Peter - 4 comments
Comments:
Feb 2013 Rainforest Crunch was the best ice cream EVER. I just saw online Hagen Dazs is making a LIMITED EDITION Caramel Truffle ice cream and I wonder if I added chopped cashews if it would be close to Rainforest Crunch?
Added 4 years ago by guest, 1 point Vote + to improve this comment's ranking Vote - to decrease this comment's ranking
Ben and Jerrys all time BEST
Added 5 years ago by guest, 0 points Vote + to improve this comment's ranking Vote - to decrease this comment's ranking
That sounds AMAZING!
Added 7 years ago by guest, 0 points Vote + to improve this comment's ranking Vote - to decrease this comment's ranking
Vanilla Ice Cream with Rainforest Crunch, a Cashew & Brazil Nut Butter Crunch. This flavor ran for 7 years.
Added 8 years ago by Peter, 1 point Vote + to improve this comment's ranking Vote - to decrease this comment's ranking

6.

Vote + to improve this item's ranking
Vote - to decrease this item's ranking
Appley Ever After (brown sugar ice cream with cinammon, caramel and fruit) Report Abuse
Appeared in an AARP crossword puzzle
21 points - added 7 years ago by guest - 1 comment
Comments:
it was the best ice cream in the whole entire world. I hate ben and jerrys for stopping it. screw them
Added 6 years ago by guest, 0 points Vote + to improve this comment's ranking Vote - to decrease this comment's ranking

7.

Vote + to improve this item's ranking
Vote - to decrease this item's ranking
World's Best Vanilla Report Abuse
This was the world's best vanilla ice cream until the formula was changed a few years ago. I even wrote the company to complain, but to no avail. Instead I received a discount coupon for the "new" Vanilla which is vastly inferior to the original.
19 points - added 7 years ago by guest - 3 comments
Comments:
Yes, I agree. That vastly inferior flavor was/is called Simply Vanilla. "SImply" is right. It was very simple by comparison to the nuanced and complex falvors of Worlds Best Vanilla, which contained 8 varieties of vanilla in the flavor formula, including the famous Tahitian Vanilla. I mourn the loss of this flavor to this day.
Added 7 years ago by AbigayilNeshama, 1 point Vote + to improve this comment's ranking Vote - to decrease this comment's ranking
You should have sent the coupon back. It would've made a good statement.
Added 7 years ago by guest, 1 point Vote + to improve this comment's ranking Vote - to decrease this comment's ranking
you are so right - and they even made it in quart size.
Added 7 years ago by lisapij, 1 point Vote + to improve this comment's ranking Vote - to decrease this comment's ranking

8.

Vote + to improve this item's ranking
Vote - to decrease this item's ranking
Cake Batter Report Abuse
18 points - added 6 years ago by guest - 2 comments
Comments:
it wasn't!!!!
Added 3 years ago by guest, 1 point Vote + to improve this comment's ranking Vote - to decrease this comment's ranking
This is just sad. Cake Batter was one of the most popular flavors made. I...I just don't understand. What did we do to deserve getting our favorite ice cream taken away?
Added 4 years ago by guest, 1 point Vote + to improve this comment's ranking Vote - to decrease this comment's ranking

9.

Vote + to improve this item's ranking
Vote - to decrease this item's ranking
Vermonty Python Report Abuse
The ice cream was simple and cute with those tasty Fudge Cows!
15 points - added 8 years ago by guest - 2 comments
Comments:
Nooo. Vermonty Python. Coffee liqueur ice cream, cookie crumble swirl, and little chocolate cows. Best flavor ever.
Added 6 years ago by guest, 3 points Vote + to improve this comment's ranking Vote - to decrease this comment's ranking
Uhhh...i think you're talking about "Bovinity Divinity"?
Added 7 years ago by guest, -1 points Vote + to improve this comment's ranking Vote - to decrease this comment's ranking

10.

Vote + to improve this item's ranking
Vote - to decrease this item's ranking
Peanut Butter and Jelly Report Abuse
14 points - added 8 years ago by Peter -

11.

Vote + to improve this item's ranking
Vote - to decrease this item's ranking
21. Jamaican Me Crazy Report Abuse
8 points - added 8 years ago by guest - 1 comment
Comments:
a fantastic ice cream that is still around today.
Added 6 years ago by guest, 0 points Vote + to improve this comment's ranking Vote - to decrease this comment's ranking

12.

Vote + to improve this item's ranking
Vote - to decrease this item's ranking
Bovinity Divinity Report Abuse
8 points - added 8 years ago by Peter -

13.

Vote + to improve this item's ranking
Vote - to decrease this item's ranking
Aztec Harvest Coffee Report Abuse
8 points - added 8 years ago by Peter -

14.

Vote + to improve this item's ranking
Vote - to decrease this item's ranking
Black & Tan Report Abuse
7 points - added 8 years ago by Peter -

15.

Vote + to improve this item's ranking
Vote - to decrease this item's ranking
Banana Ice Cream Report Abuse
5 points - added 8 years ago by Peter - 1 comment
Comments:
eww
Added 6 years ago by guest, 0 points Vote + to improve this comment's ranking Vote - to decrease this comment's ranking

16.

Vote + to improve this item's ranking
Vote - to decrease this item's ranking
Ethan Almond Report Abuse
5 points - added 8 years ago by Peter - 1 comment
Comments:
haha
Added 6 years ago by guest, 0 points Vote + to improve this comment's ranking Vote - to decrease this comment's ranking

17.

Vote + to improve this item's ranking
Vote - to decrease this item's ranking
Raspberry Gone Coconuts Low Fat Frozen Yogurt Report Abuse
And I quote "A radical recipe of raspberry and toasted coconut frozen yogurts with buttery chunks of coconut cookies." I have been searching for the description thinking I made it up in my head. It was amazing! Perfect match of lightly coconut flavored cookie chunks with the fruit combo- it was like a shortbread jam cookie/bar. Why do B&J's release so few Fro Yo options?
1 point - added 7 years ago by guest - 2 comments
Comments:
I crave this flavor and have relentlessly scoured store freezers. I came across this site while attempting to order it online! SO sad to find out its been discontinued :(
Added 4 years ago by guest, -1 points Vote + to improve this comment's ranking Vote - to decrease this comment's ranking
I agree, the best ever!
Added 7 years ago by guest, 1 point Vote + to improve this comment's ranking Vote - to decrease this comment's ranking

18.

Vote + to improve this item's ranking
Vote - to decrease this item's ranking
Purple Passion Fruit Report Abuse
1 point - added 8 years ago by Peter -

19.

Vote + to improve this item's ranking
Vote - to decrease this item's ranking
Sugar Plum Report Abuse
1 point - added 8 years ago by Peter -

20.

Vote + to improve this item's ranking
Vote - to decrease this item's ranking
One Sweet Whirled Report Abuse
So good!
0 points - added 4 years ago by guest -

21.

Vote + to improve this item's ranking
Vote - to decrease this item's ranking
Holy Cannoli Report Abuse
(1987-1988): Creamy ricotta and pistachio ice cream with chocolate-cannoli bits and roasted pistachios. My all time favorite ice cream flavor. The ricotta makes it richer with more depth. Chocolate covered waffle cone-like cookie pieces but better than waffle cone. I think people were afraid of it because it said ricotta on the label and they couldn't get around the thought of having cheese in their ice cream. Fantastic flavor.
0 points - added 7 years ago by guest - 2 comments
Comments:
Still think about this flavor..miss it!
Added 6 months ago by guest, 1 point Vote + to improve this comment's ranking Vote - to decrease this comment's ranking
The Best
Added 4 years ago by guest, 1 point Vote + to improve this comment's ranking Vote - to decrease this comment's ranking

22.

Vote + to improve this item's ranking
Vote - to decrease this item's ranking
Brownie Bars Report Abuse
-1 point - added 8 years ago by Peter -

23.

Vote + to improve this item's ranking
Vote - to decrease this item's ranking
Bluesberry Low Fat Frozen Yogurt Report Abuse
-3 points - added 8 years ago by Peter -

24.

Vote + to improve this item's ranking
Vote - to decrease this item's ranking
Blackberry Cobbler Report Abuse
-3 points - added 8 years ago by Peter -

25.

Vote + to improve this item's ranking
Vote - to decrease this item's ranking
Tennessee Mud Report Abuse
-3 points - added 8 years ago by Peter - 2 comments
Comments:
a medium flavor wasnt great wasnt bad
Added 6 years ago by guest, 0 points Vote + to improve this comment's ranking Vote - to decrease this comment's ranking
Very delicious flavor that consisted of Coffee Ice Cream with Amaretto, Jack Daniels Tennessee Whiskey and Roasted Slivered Almonds
Added 8 years ago by Peter, 0 points Vote + to improve this comment's ranking Vote - to decrease this comment's ranking

26.

Vote + to improve this item's ranking
Vote - to decrease this item's ranking
Devil's Food Chocolate Report Abuse
-3 points - added 8 years ago by Peter -

27.

Vote + to improve this item's ranking
Vote - to decrease this item's ranking
Cappuccino Chocolate Chunk Report Abuse
-4 points - added 8 years ago by Peter -

28.

Vote + to improve this item's ranking
Vote - to decrease this item's ranking
Economic Crunch Report Abuse
Vanilla with Chocolate Covered Almond, Pecans & Walnuts. This flavor was made in 1987.
-4 points - added 8 years ago by Peter -

29.

Vote + to improve this item's ranking
Vote - to decrease this item's ranking
Blondies are a Swirl's Best Friend Report Abuse
-5 points - added 8 years ago by Peter -

30.

Vote + to improve this item's ranking
Vote - to decrease this item's ranking
Fresh Georgia Peach Report Abuse
-6 points - added 8 years ago by Peter - 1 comment
Comments:
Vanilla Ice Cream with Fresh Georgia Peaches. This flavor existed for 5 years.
Added 8 years ago by Peter, 0 points Vote + to improve this comment's ranking Vote - to decrease this comment's ranking

31.

Vote + to improve this item's ranking
Vote - to decrease this item's ranking
White Russian Report Abuse
-6 points - added 8 years ago by Peter - 1 comment
Comments:
Coffee Ice Cream with Kahlua Coffee Liqueur
Added 8 years ago by Peter, 0 points Vote + to improve this comment's ranking Vote - to decrease this comment's ranking
Similar Top lists
ShareRanks is about ranking things that are top, most, greatest, or even worst in all categories.
Use arrows to rank one item in Best Discontinued Ben and Jerry's Ice Cream Flavors vs another.
Top 10 Best Discontinued Ben and Jerry's Ice Cream Flavors are especially marked