Best Broadway Musicals of All Time
412 items ranked
Click on up and down arrows to affect item's ranking
1.
This Pulitzer Prize and Tony Award-winning musical dazzled more than 6 million people during its record-breaking 15-year run on Broadway
Comments:
You needed to see this show on Broadway or at least the official road show. The final scene was worth the price of admission. Actors in rehersal the curtain comes down then goes up a minute later and everyone is on stage in full show dress. It was the single best scene I have ever seen. Since the choreography is copy righted most presentations must use another approach.
how the hell did it get all the way up here?!?!
that is not just over-rated, thats absurd!!
Just Did The Production. Only had 10 rehearsals, Fantastic Production. Played Paul.... Favorite Part of all time!!!!! I Really Connected with him, for the days I was him in and out of the show
The cheorography in ACL was outstanding, a lasting tribute to Michael Bennett's genius and work with dancers; the original was better than the last revival and had more heart, Donna McKechnie was great as the original Cassie!
Huh? Every song was a showstopper! The revival was great! The movie changed the show too much, but this is about Broadway musicals and this one is amazing.
the movie did not do well even with michael douglas in it, besides what I did for love and one, the songs were so-so, the revival a few years ago was just ok
3.
Gilbert and Sullivan are the British fathers of the American Theatre and this Pirates might be there best.
Comments:
A great musical that laid the foundation for most musicals that have come after it. The story is straightforward but interesting and the music is beautiful and memorable.
5.
Comments:
you have your own opinion, Sweeney Todd was greater - a Sondheim masterpiece
Who keeps knocking the greats? This is Sondheim's best and Sondheim has been America's best for a half century.
music and lyrics will stand the test of time, the book was so-so, was bobby gay?
6.
Comments:
Looking at how much a show grossed is not a good measure. When I saw Chorus Line on Broadway the top ticket was $25. Today it would be $125 and in ten years it will be $200.
So to you, the Hunchback of Notre Dame sucked, The prince of Egypt sucked, Godspell sucked, Pocahontas sucked, and Pippin sucked? Just checking. All i know is that Wicked is the 3rd highest grossing musical ever, behind Lion King and Phantom, and its run isnt even over yet. Also Wicked is one of the top 15 longest running musicals of all time and again, its run on Broadway isnt even close to being over.
Everything that Schwartz ever touched has been terrible. Wicked is no exception.
This musical should be NUMBER 1! Because of it I'm now kind of obsessed with Idina Menzel and I 'm listening defying gravity like every day. I wished ticket for Wicked for my birthday :)
This musical should be in top ten on this list! It has a good story and very memorable songs .
Mediocre music? All you need to do is mention defying gravity and people go nuts! Not to mention For Good, No Good Deed, As long as your Mine, and No one mourns the Wicked! And in my opinion, Wicked has one of the most compeling story lines of any musical. Its one tht make you think, makes you ponder what is good and what is evil.
Should be so much higher! More directed for younger girls, but still a great one!
Mediocre music. Week story line that has many errors in trying to go match with Wizard of Oz. After being down around #50 where it belongs for years, it has had a mediocre rise, as if one person is spending all of their time voting for it. This is by far the most overrated musical on the list.
This is most certainly more interesting than number 14. Wicked should be in the top 10 at least, along with the Lion King, Phantom, Rent, and Les Miserables.
Wicked is truly a sepectical to behold. The costumes, scene design, score, and story makes it the worldwide bestseller it is today. It has also had one of the biggest turnarounds in theatre history. When it first came out, no critic believd in it. now 7 years later, wicked has become one of the best musicals in history and is now getting the reviews it deserved. example being the recent "musical of the decade" bestowed by Entertainment Weekly
It's my favorite musical of all time, should be higher on the list. Maybe #3? And Phantom should be up there too.
Very pop musical-like, but not a quality music overall. It will never be a classic.
What are you talking about! It is an Amazing! It has an amazing score tht makes you laugh, cry, and amazes you with inspirational power! In short everything about this musical amkes it a top ten player. If it wasn't it wouldn't bee CURRENTly running its 8th year on Broadway!
Dreadful musical. Cool sets and all - but that's it. Horrible songs, confused book, icky orchestrations. OK if you are a 14 year old girl, I guess.
way overrated, it did not do well in SF when it opened, really can not hum or remember the songs
This musical was amazing it was funny, creative, and it almost made me cry. this should be #1 on this list
best show i've ever seen in my life. the graphics were amazing, such an amazing show, and you can compare it with the wizard of oz and it just all makes sense.
8.
Comments:
You probably haven't seen a good production of it. South Pacific has so many good songs and moves along so quickly that the real concern is missing some of the detail. I hope you get to see a really good production of it, like one that has been on Broadway for the past year.
Though this show is very well respected, I find it long and slow.
9.
The version on Broadway with Kristin Chenoweth and Sean Hayes is even better than the 1960's version with Jerry Orbach. Neil Simon's book and the music of Burt Bacharach with Hal David's lyrics make it a touching, funny, wonderful show!
Comments:
The music is great, fits the music, is timely with the script, and is as enjoyable now as it was when it was originally written.
A great musical show, with great songs, an interesting story, and great humor.
I just saw this Saturday night and Kristin Chenoweth is outstanding! She brought the house down twice with her singing and really gets to the heart of the role. Sean Hayes is even better! He was so funny. It was the best theatre experience I have had in years.
you are way over rating this flashback, Chenoweth was miscast, the book is dated
mad men made it a good time to revive
though the music is passe
10.
Romeo and Juliet put to the timeless score of Leonard Bernstein, the pointed lyrics of Stephen Sondheim and the energetic choreography of Jerome Robbins. With all due respect to other musicals, this is simply the best of all time.
Comments:
I thought this was a bit boring. I mean, I appreaciate it, for the work put in and music written, but the classical ballet street thugs was.. cheesy. I was also surprised (not in a good way) at the ending which was different from Romeo and Juliet (the play it is based off).
i LOVE this play :) i played Maria when my school did a production of it, first time acting and best experience of my life, but it was nothing compared to seeing Natalie Wood and Richard Beymer on the big screen :D
This is sooo beautiful musical! I love Tonight and I feel preety. The first time I saw it I was shocked when Chino shot Tony so I started to hate Chino :)
Leonard Bernstein is truely one of the greatest composers of Musical Theatre of all time. One of teh best scores there is (joint first with Les mis).
I loved this movie since the age of 7. ( even though I didn't know much what it was about though..) It is AMAZING!!!!!!
i remember watching my 1st musical when i was a kid, had a crush on natalie (though I read later that she really didn't sing there), remember crying in the end as i found the story so tragic. best of all time? have to agree
11.
Comments:
Besides a great book and characters has nothing but hit after hit after hit. . . .count them all
That would be so wonderful if Eliza was Julie Andrews. I bought cd with with her and Rex Harrison. i listen it every night before I go to bed:)
witty, moving, funny... just brilliant (with or without julie andrews)
Funny, bitingly ironic, and yet somehow also quite romantically moving. The music is beautiful, the lyrics masterfully witty. On top of all that, the original characterization by Rex Harrison was one of the greatest in theater history.
PYGMALIAN wow that was a fantastic movie and Broadway show. Even the book was fantastic. LOVED this SHOW!
With Julie Andrews: NUMBER ONE.
Without Julie Andrews: down there in the 30-something.. ^^
12.
Comments:
There is no other musical that matches the wit and the magic of Guys and Dolls as the quintessential Broadway musical. The loveable larrikins of Runyon, a score that shames pretenders for all their lack of impact on the memory and the delightful humor of the script leaves one wondering why this masterpiece lingers at number 7 on this list!
13.
Comments:
This is beyond genius, I think this play is nearly perfect. Rodgers and Hammerstein are genious; this play is a classic all the way. Who DOESNT know the song Doe a Dear? For musical junkies, this is one of the first plays you get to know inside and out. Julie Andrews is phenomenal, this play is well worth it.
16.
Comments:
This is a great musical. The subject matter is perfect for a musical. It is in depth, with great characters accurately portrayed, with great music and exciting plot. It is excellent.
This is one of the great shows of all time. It stays fairly true to the history (although Jefferson had just come from home and had not been away 6 months). Great music, great patriotism, great wit. But it takes incredible singers and actors to pull it off. You must have seen a bad production, because the ones that I have seen have been stirring, exciting, and outstanding!
1776 is the worst show I've ever seen. Why is it on this list? Bleck, it was 3 hours long and the plot was all old-president-dudes arguing. The songs did nothing to enhance the action. WORST 3 HOURS OF MY LIFE EVER
17.
The oft forgotten outstanding musical from the 50's that takes us back to the late 1800's in Britian.
18.
20.
Perhaps one of the best broadway scores ever, brassy (Styne) with Sondheim lyrics to boot. Each Mama Rose has carved out her own mark in the lead role (Merman, Lansbury, Daly, Peters and LuPone).
33.
Based on a novel by the same name by Victor Hugo, this musical has had the longest innings in the history of theatre.
Comments:
This is the greatest musical of all time: Music, story, characters, message are all exceptional.
Incredible show, the fact that it is below wicked makes me want to vomit.
This is the best musical ever! Every time I watch Come to me or Do you hear the people sing I almost start to cry. I'm also reading the book now and when you read the first 2 hundred pages the story becames really interesting. I also understand musical better now.
This is the best musical ever. It shouls be NUMBER 1! Why is it so low?! It has so touching story and most incredible songs. Number 42, seriously?
Seriously?!?! Number 33? I'm really disappointed in whoever wrote this list. Phantom at #238, Les Mis here...those two (and other masterpieces) should be WAY higher up on the list.
THIS IS THE BEST MUSICAL EVER!!!!!!! GORGEOUS MUSIC, PERFECT STORY!!!!!!!!! SHOULD BE #1!!!!!!
Love this musical! Great story and even better score! But again, if half the people who say this should be higher clicked the green arrow next to the name, it would be in the top ten. Just sayin :)
"THE BEST MUSICAL OF ALL TIME" PERIOD.
This Musical should be number 1!!
It's just unfortunate that so many snob les mis because of it's popularity when it is truly one of the greatest shows of all time.
best musical eve in my opinion. i played this at school, and even the condensed school version is amazingly intricate and detailled. and the music is gorgeous.
This Musical should be number 1 who made this!!!!! les miserables is breathtaking the person who made this obviously hasn't heard it done well
#33? Are you kidding? Les Miserables is the greatest musical in history! Should be top three on any list...
ONE OF THE BEST!!!!! how could you put this at 35 and i dont care how 'inaccurate' it is it is still one of the best things to come to music for over 50 years thank you very much!
Way too dark to be at the top of the list. And way too inaccurate historically to be taken as seriously as some do.
OI! THIS SHOULD BE NUMBER ONE! There's no way Annie can be #5, by the way. Good lead actors are not the best Litmus Test for musicals. And, emotional-appeal-orphan-story doesn't possibly stand up to the supreme conflict plot in Les Mis.
I'm completely confused why this isn't at least in the tope five. And where the hell is Phantom?
37.
Based on the novel by Gaston Leroux, this Broadway musical by Andrew Lloyd Webberis is the winner of seven 1988 Tony Awards.
Comments:
Should be at the top 5, one of the most moving musicals. One of Andrew's best musicals and one of the best the world has ever seen.
I love phantom. I read the book, an original screnplay, I bought souvenir book when I was in London, I watched the show, the film for like hundred times and listened cd. I only have to buy the mask now :) Seriously, I'm obsessed.
This should be NUMBER 1! Because of phantom I started to love musicals. I saw the show in London with Tabitha Web and David Shannon and it was AMAZING! I also loved the film. I just can't understan why is it at 122 !?! This musical will be popular forever.
I agree that this should be ALOT higher (personally this is my second favortie musical behind wicked) but what people dont seem to get is thtNO One person made this list, you did. the red and green arrows are for you to click to move this up. if half the people who complain tht should be higher clicked the little green arrow by the name, this would be in the top 50 by now! :)
Some people have no god dam taste. It a fantastic musical reguardless of your obviously biased opinion of Andrew Lloyd Webber. Please move it up!
Yes, the longest running Broadway musical is 400th on a list behind things like 'We Will Rock You', 'Jumbo' and 'The Life'. Who paid you to make this list and/or are your ears broken?
this is one of my favorite musicals and the first one i saw. Why is it way down at 400
This should be in the top 5. the person who made this is an IDIOT.
38.
Comments:
"Opera existed first. Therefore musical theatre is opera."
This logic does not work...
Opera existed first. Therefore musical theatre is opera. not the other way around
Porgy and Bess won the 1977 Tony Award for Innovative Musical Revival
Opera is musical theatre. There are many crossovers. Technically, Les Mis, Jesus Christ Superstar, and Tommy are operas (the last two rock operas), but are accepted as musical theatre as well. Porgy and Bess is one of Gershwin's best. It has played in opera houses, but also in Broadway theatres. It is an amazing show.
39.
Comments:
The Producers is definitely in my top ten favorite musicals! It's one of the funniest musicals i've seen! Great book, great score, and the original cast had some of the best actors in musical theatre history! Nathan Lane, Matthew Broderick, Gary Beach, they are all fantastic! And, like others said, this show one more tony's than any other musical in history! Thats gotta tell you something :)
I agree this show won 12 Tony Awards the most in history and is arguably the most successful show on Broadway
When you have Nathan Lane and Matthew Broderick, it's automatically good, and it won more tony's than any other show in history. Great music and totally hilarious.
40.
In the exciting era of Ragtime, the lives of a wealthy family, a poor immigrant and his motherless daughter, and a black man named Coalhouse Walker, intertwine.Blessed with beauty, ambition, a smashing wardrobe and a social conscience, "Ragtime" is the kind of musical that brings Broadway audiences to their knees in adoration.Based on the 1975 novel by E. L. Doctorow, Ragtime tells the story of three groups in America, represented by Coalhouse Walker Jr., a Harlem musician; Mother, the matriarch of a WASP family in New Rochelle, NY; and Tateh, a Latvian Jewish immigrant. Historical figures such as Houdini, Evelyn Nesbit, Booker T. Washington, J. P. Morgan, Henry Ford, Stanford White, Harry Kendall Thaw, Admiral Peary, Matthew Henson, and Emma Goldman also appear. The music includes marches, cakewalks, gospel and ragtime.
46.
Comments:
49 isn't bad. Not out of the top 400 Broadway musicals of all time. It is a great show, but only one showstopper, "Send in the Clowns." But then again, Sondheim is known more for good, but complicated, music, rather than showstoppers.
50.
The Impossible Dream might be the most stirring and inspiring song ever in a Broadway musical! The rest of the musical is excellent, but The Impossible Dream is possibly the all time showstopper.
51.
Rodgers & Hart's 1937 hit starring Alfred Drake and the Nicholas Brothers included hit songs, "My Funny Valentine," "Where or When," "Johnny One Note," and "The Lady is a Tramp."
57.
Comments:
i liked it, it was clever, the score was great, my only problem is that it is a bit too long
One of my favorite musicals and even if you hate the music, you should respect the deep sadness of the story.
personally my favorite musical. bernadette peters was amazing, and the music is soooo unbelievably difficult.
We did this musical in highschool and it is great. It definitely has some deep meaning. Not annoying at all (in my opinion).
patronizing attitude show, sunday in the park with george has much more in it
Into the Woods is one of the deepest shows that has ever been written, in my opinion. I might have agreed with you before I got the chance to really SEE the show. But, now that I see all of the power behind it, and all of the deep meaning Sondheim gave us through this show, I would say it's one of my favorites of all time.
59.
"Phantom of the opera sequel" that really stands alone! Great singing, acting and fun story! :)
Comments:
Personally I love this musical. It absolutely should have come to Broadway. It was going to until ALW was diagnosed with prostrate cancer. Then things got postponed... and damn no musical. Its such a shame it went off West End. Hopefully one day it will come back, unfortunately I do not see that in the near future. What a magnificent score.
most amazing musical i have seen i loved it so so so so much i think some of the music was even better than phantom ! i am in love with it :D:D so beautiful the charecters where all so much more 3 dimensional in this one. i saw the melbourne one, not the london one. IT WAS PHANTASTIC :D:D
65.
Running for 18 years on Broadway, this musical by Andrew Lloyd Webber is based on Old Possum’s Book of Practical Cats by T S Elliot.
Comments:
Sure it has a plot! My favourite musical ever and it should be higher on this list.
this is one of the musicals that teach us that if you have enough money for production, you don't need any talent... i remember when i saw it i just kept asking myself where the hell is the plot?!?!
the only reason that it running so long is just because people like colorful things jumping infront of them.
This musical has so amazing songs. I just can't stop siging memory to myself. It should be in top ten! I watched the film and I was astonishment about dancing and costumes and singing. I love cats.
There IS a plot, it's just a little weird. It takes some time to understand it. For the songs, they're just incredible, and with a brilliant choreography... this should definitely be a little higher on the list...
Why the hell is Cats all the way down here? It's the second longest running Broadway musical of all time! It's loved by young and old. However voted this down dosen't know a good musical when they see one. And of course it's not gonna have the best plot line...It's based of a bunch of poems! Just appreciate the music and dancing.
Should be number one in my opinion, or at least in the top 10. Sorry for the rant. ^^;
i agree, it has barely any plot. but plot alone doesn't make a hit. What makes this Musical a classic is just that. THE MUSIC. go up to any drama student, or actor and tell them to name one song from Cats and you will most likely get one.
It is a spectacle of cats, but with no plot and not that interesting. Entertaining to the masses, but not art.
71.
Comments:
The lyrical phrasing and just plain badassery of this show blows my mind. Sondheim's best by far.
73.
Rodgers & Hart's 1937 hit starred George M. Cohan as President Franklin Roosevelt, singing and dancing.
75.
Comments:
Barbra Streisand is so great. I love her voice and she's great in every musical but Funny girl is realy great. Especialy Don't rain on my parade and I'd rather be blue :)
76.
Rogers and Hammersteins best. Subtle and moving, the lyrics and music evoke character and plot, exemplifying the artistic power of musical theatre. One of the top 10 musicals of all time.
78.
Comments:
definitely should be way closer to the top, one of the greatest shows ever!
This should be in the top ten!! It humanizes Christ more than anything an makes us apreciate Him more!
87.
Victor Herbert's 1906 Broadway musical hit included the songs, "Moodbeams" and "In Old New York."
90.
Comments:
I love story, songs and dance. All together makes a great show and fantastic experience! It should be in top ten.
92.
Comments:
I dont understand why this show gets soo much grief because isnt the entire movie put on stage. They combined the books and the movie! And sure they rewrote some of the songs, but thts wht makes it original! Quite frankly id rather pay to this than the movie put on stage, because youd basically paying to see the movie again! I welcome the change, and personally believe tht this, beauty and the beast, and the liopn king are disneys best musical work! :)
93.
Victor Herbert's 1910 Broadway hit included "Ah, Sweet Mystery of Life," and "I'm Falling in Love With Someone," both of which reappeared in Thoroughly Modern Millie in 2002.
Comments:
Yes it was produced by Oscar Hammerstein I, but he was Oscar Hammerstein II's grandfather, not his father. Willie Hammerstein was the II's father, he was a stage musical and theatre manager.
95.
Jerome Kern's music made this 1933 musical that included, "Smoke Gets In Your Eyes," "Let's Begin," and "Yesterdays."
Similar Top lists
| Category | Ranked | Added by | |
|---|---|---|---|
| Greatest Bass Players of All Time | Music | 411 items | pxc0 |
| Best Brazilian Albums of All Time | Music | 22 items | bluefin33 |
| The Most Popular Classical Music Pieces of All Time | Music | 35 items | thewordwarrior |
| Best Broadway Musicals of the 2000s | Music | 20 items | plink |
| Best Broadway Musicals of the 1980s | Music | 20 items | plink |
ShareRanks is about ranking things that are top, most, greatest, or even worst in all categories.
Use arrows to rank one item in Best Broadway Musicals of All Time vs another.
Use arrows to rank one item in Best Broadway Musicals of All Time vs another.
Top 10 Best Broadway Musicals of All Time are especially marked









